Natural deodorants have taken the wellness world by storm, and for good reason. They skip the harsh chemicals, heavy fragrances, and aluminum compounds found in traditional antiperspirants, offering a cleaner, more mindful way to stay fresh.
But one ingredient has sparked plenty of debate: baking soda.
While some people swear by baking soda deodorant for its odor-fighting power, others find it too harsh for their skin. So, what’s the deal? Let’s break down the science, the pros and cons, and the best EarthHero options for every skin type.
H2: What Is Baking Soda Deodorant?
Baking soda (also known as sodium bicarbonate) has long been used as a natural deodorizer. You’ll find it in everything from toothpaste to household cleaners. In deodorant, baking soda helps neutralize odor by balancing pH and absorbing moisture from sweat.
It’s effective, affordable, and natural…so what’s not to love? Well, for some, the problem isn’t performance but sensitivity.
Baking Soda vs. Baking Soda-Free Deodorant
1) How Baking Soda Works
Baking soda works by creating a more alkaline environment on the skin, which helps prevent odor-causing bacteria from thriving. This means it can be a powerful, natural alternative to synthetic ingredients found in conventional deodorants.
But there’s a catch: the skin’s natural pH is slightly acidic, and baking soda’s alkalinity can disrupt that balance. Over time, this may lead to irritation, dryness, or redness, especially in the sensitive underarm area.
Baking soda is a known skin irritant when used in high concentrations or on sensitive skin because of its higher pH (around 9), compared to the skin’s normal pH (around 5.5). This difference can weaken your skin barrier, leading to inflammation or even contact dermatitis.
2) How Baking Soda-Free Deodorants Differ
Baking soda-free deodorants take a gentler approach. Instead of using sodium bicarbonate, they rely on natural alternatives like magnesium hydroxide, zinc ricinoleate, arrowroot powder, or activated charcoal to absorb moisture and fight odor without altering your skin’s natural balance.
Magnesium hydroxide, for example, neutralizes odor-causing bacteria without affecting pH, making it a top choice for those prone to irritation.
Formulation experts have noted that ingredients maintaining the skin’s natural barrier are better tolerated and less likely to cause rashes or sensitivity than high-alkaline agents like baking soda.
The Pros and Cons of Baking Soda Deodorant
Pros:
-
Highly effective at controlling odor
-
Natural and non-toxic alternative to aluminum-based antiperspirants
-
Absorbs moisture well to help you stay dry
-
Widely available in both cream and stick formulas
Cons:
-
Can cause irritation or redness, especially on freshly shaved skin
-
May lead to itchiness or burning for those with sensitive skin
-
Not ideal for daily long-term use on compromised skin
In short, baking soda deodorants work brilliantly for some people, but if you have sensitive skin, you might find them too harsh.
Signs You Might Need a Baking Soda-Free Deodorant
If you’ve been using baking soda deodorant and noticed:
-
Persistent redness or dryness
-
Tiny bumps or itchiness under your arms
-
Burning after application
...it may be time to switch to a baking soda-free formula. Even if you love the performance, irritation is your skin’s way of saying it needs something gentler.
The Best Baking Soda Deodorants on EarthHero
If your skin can handle it, baking soda deodorant can be a game-changer for odor control. Here are a few top-rated picks that use minimal, effective ingredients and sustainable packaging.
1. Zero Waste Deodorant Stick by Meow Meow Tweet
Shop Now
Made with baking soda, magnesium, and arrowroot powder, this compostable tube deodorant neutralizes odor while keeping your pits silky soft. It’s vegan, plastic-free, and available in multiple scents.
2. Fat and the Moon Aluminum-Free Deodorant Cream
Shop Now
A creamy, nourishing formula that uses baking soda and coconut oil for all-day odor protection, handmade in small batches.
3. Zero Waste Deodorant Cream by Meow Meow Tweet
Perfect for those who love a hands-on approach, this rich cream uses baking soda, kaolin clay, and arrowroot to absorb moisture, and essential oils to keep you fresh.
4. The Deep Deodorant by Routine
Formulated for long-lasting freshness, this baking soda-based deodorant cream is perfect for those with active lifestyles.
5. Coastal Forests Deodorant by Routine
Infused with pine and eucalyptus notes, this eco-conscious deodorant cream combines baking soda and clay for natural odor protection.
The Best Baking Soda-Free Deodorants on EarthHero
If your skin needs something gentler, you’ll find plenty of baking soda-free deodorants that still deliver on performance.
1. Sensitive Skin Deodorant by Sustain Yourself
This magnesium-based deodorant keeps odor at bay without disrupting your skin’s pH. A must for sensitive pits.
2. Spray Deodorant (Baking Soda-Free)
Light, refreshing, and easy to apply, this baking soda-free formula is ideal for those who prefer a quick spritz over a cream or stick.
3. Baking Soda-Free Zero Waste Deodorant Stick
An EarthHero bestseller, this compostable stick features magnesium hydroxide and arrowroot for irritation-free freshness.
4. Baking Soda-Free Zero Waste Deodorant Cream
Smooth and soothing, this cream uses arrowroot and magnesium to gently absorb moisture. No irritation, no residue.
5. Whole Body Deodorant
A multitasking deodorant that works beyond the underarms. Gentle, effective, and completely baking soda-free.
6. Fat and the Moon Sensitive Pit Deodorant Cream
Made with arrowroot powder and nourishing plant oils, this formula delivers smooth application with zero sting.
Want to know more about baking-soda-free deodorants? Check out our guide here.
Baking Soda or Baking Soda-Free: Which One Should You Choose?
Ultimately, the best deodorant for you depends on your skin type and lifestyle. Here’s a quick breakdown:
|
Skin Type |
Best Option |
Why It Works |
|
Normal |
Baking Soda Deodorant |
Great odor control, simple formula |
|
Sensitive |
Baking Soda-Free Deodorant |
Gentle ingredients, balanced pH |
|
Very Active / Sweaty |
Baking Soda or Magnesium-Based |
Strong odor absorption |
|
Dry Skin |
Baking Soda-Free with Shea or Coconut |
Moisturizing and soothing |
If you’re unsure, start with a baking soda-free deodorant to give your skin time to adjust, especially if you’re transitioning from conventional antiperspirants.
Tips for Switching to Natural Deodorant
Transitioning to natural deodorant (with or without baking soda) takes patience. Here are a few tips to make it easier:
-
Expect a short detox phase. Your body may take a week or two to rebalance after switching from antiperspirants.
-
Stay consistent. Apply daily (and reapply if needed during hot weather or workouts).
-
Exfoliate gently. Use a mild scrub once a week to prevent buildup and irritation.
-
Listen to your skin. If redness or itching occurs, switch to a gentler formula.
For more support, check out our blog on Natural Deodorants for step-by-step tips.
The Bottom Line
So, is baking soda deodorant best for your skin? It depends.
If your skin loves it, you’ll enjoy one of the most effective natural odor-fighting ingredients around. But if irritation strikes, it’s not a failure, it just means your skin prefers something gentler. Luckily, there’s a baking soda-free deodorant for every body type and scent preference.
Whether you need a strong performer for active days or a soft touch for sensitive skin, EarthHero’s collection has you covered with low-waste, clean, and cruelty-free options that keep you (and your conscience) fresh.
Explore all Natural Deodorants at EarthHero and find the formula that fits you best.
